Girl Online, but not on my favorites list.
Girl Online follows Penny, a girl from England who runs a popular blog that details her everyday life and suffers from anxiety and panic attacks. After drama at school sends her anxiety through the roof, Penny happily travels with her family to the states so her mother can plan a Christmas wedding. Once in the Big Apple, Penny falls for a gorgeous boy.
Even though I follow Zoe Sugg, known as Zoella on Youtube, I don’t watch her videos frequently enough to know that she had a young adult series. When I first saw this book, I assumed it was an autobiography. However, my sister informed that it was a young adult book and a lot of controversy surrounded it because people questioned how much Zoe Sugg actually wrote. I will not focus my review on this controversy, but instead review its content as I would for any other young adult book.
First, I’ll begin with the positives. Even though Penny’s situation most likely wouldn’t happen in real life, I thought she was a relatable young adult character. Many readers also struggle with anxiety and hope to make it big on the internet. I also thought Penny’s voice was very realistic and I actually found myself reading the book in Zoe’s voice.
I also really enjoyed the last twenty pages or so of the book a lot. I thought the action was really great and I saw Penny growing as a character and finally standing up for herself. However, I was also slightly disappointed in the end because all the growth was instantly dropped the moment the boy came back into the picture. I know there is another book in this series and another one the way, so I think I would be more interested to pick up the next books if the drama remained unresolved between Penny and her love interest.
While I liked Penny and her growth towards the end of the book, I do have several problems with this book. First off is the plot. Besides the end of the novel, most of the book is plot-driven rather than character-driven and consists of “cute” moments between Penny and Noah. A lot of these moments have been done numerous times before and I just found the doll part a little strange. I also think the foreshadowing of Noah’s “secret” was way too predictable. No event in this book really set it apart from books in the same genre.
Many of the characters also fell into typical stereotypes. Her best friend was always a villain, her crush was a good guy trapped in the clutches of the evil (but extremely talented girl), and Noah was the perfect guy. Her true best friend (I can’t remember his name), also was problematic for me. I understand he had family problems and Penny was really his only friend, but I think the author made him too jealous most of the time. Even though he was definitely one of the more complex characters in the book, the constant jealousy made him a tad unlikable to me.
I’ve read many books similar to Girl Online that I’ve rated three stars, however, I have to give Girl Online only two stars because I just didn’t enjoy it like other books I’ve read with similar plots. I found myself constantly putting down and not wanting to pick it up again. When I finally got into it, I was only disappointed by the ending.
10 thoughts on “Teen Tuesday: Girl Online Review”
I shied away from reading Girl Online because I expected it to be generically corny. Thanks for writing such a detailed review! While I love Zoella, I’m happy to enjoy her as a personality rather than a writer.
LikeLiked by 2 people
What a detailed post! I always assumed it was an autobiography too… I don’t really watch Zoella’s Youtube videos. Do you have an opinion on the drama that surrounded this book – that pars were written by a ghost writer? What do you think about the surge in Youtubers who are releasing books? Good or bad? I’d be interested to hear what you think x
For the controversy, surrounding this book, I am in the middle. Based on the statements released about this book, I can’t judge how much Zoe actually wrote so it would be unfair to demand her to credit the ghostwriter on the title page when so many other celebrities and Youtube personalities probably receive the same amount of help but a fraction of the backlash. Zoe also admitted that she did receive help, but I do think more transparency would have aided her situation. I think overall, I am not as infuriated as other people because this didn’t start with Zoe and it won’t end with Zoe either. While it isn’t unreasonable to expect more from the people we admire, she isn’t solely to blame. The book industry is a business, so one of its goals is to make money, even though we ideally wish it would only publish what we consider “great” literature. In short, I appreciate an author’s integrity if they are very transparent about their book, but I also understand that the author is not solely to blame.
As for books by other Youtubers, I haven’t read any (yet!). I’m not surprised in the surge though because their popularity combined with the extra money that their target audience has would lead to a lot of book sales. I’ve heard so many children say they want to be Youtuber when they grow up! I’m also not surprised because Youtubers do write their own content regularly, even if it isn’t a full length book. Youtubers definitely are creative, which is also characteristic of authors. I guess the only reason I haven’t read many is that quite a few are autobiographies, which I don’t normally read. On one hand, I think it is good because people who may not normally read books may be inclined to if their favorite Youtuber advertises it on their channel. On the other hand, like with any influential person, people just have to be careful not idolize Youtubers’ fame and fortune. It’s easy to assume that a person is (and will always be) great, especially with autobiographies, but it’s important to remember that people make mistakes (and that’s completely normal!). I guess the recent Youtube surge doesn’t bother me because there’s always a new trend in literature (Youtube books, dystopian, etc.) and if it doesn’t interest me, I just find something else to read!
Sorry this was really long, but I hope that I answered your questions!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for such a fabulous and thoughtful response! I completely understand where you’re coming from on both points and this was a great answer 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your such a good writer! This review was awesome! I know it’s an old post but I love this book and I was looking around on WordPress for some good accounts! Keep on writing reviews and check out my account when your free!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
[…] Girl Online by Zoe Sugg focused too much on cute moments between the main character and her love interest, and as a result, the plot disappeared! […]
[…] Girl Online by Zoe Sugg (★ ★) […]
[…] really didn’t like Girl Online, but I think it has the perfect cover! I love the Polaroid-type pictures mixed in with the fairy […]
[…] Girl Online by Zoe Sugg […]
[…] 4.) Girl Online by Zoe Sugg […]